Skip to main content

Digital Signage Vendor Selection Guide

Choose the Right Partner

Selecting the right digital signage vendor is critical to your deployment's success. This guide provides evaluation frameworks, RFP templates, and comparison criteria to help you make an informed decision that meets your technical, operational, and budget requirements.

Vendor Selection Process​

Selection Timeline​

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                   VENDOR SELECTION PROCESS                       │
│                                                                  │
│   Week 1-2         Week 3-4         Week 5-6        Week 7-8    │
│   ┌────────┐      ┌────────┐       ┌────────┐      ┌────────┐   │
│   │Define  │  ─►  │Issue   │  ─►   │Evaluate│  ─►  │Final   │   │
│   │Require │      │RFP     │       │Proposals│     │Decision│   │
│   │-ments  │      │        │       │& Demo  │      │        │   │
│   └────────┘      └────────┘       └────────┘      └────────┘   │
│       │               │                │                │       │
│       ▼               ▼                ▼                ▼       │
│   • Needs         • Send to       • Score          • Contract   │
│     assessment      5-8 vendors     responses        negotiation│
│   • Stakeholder   • Q&A period    • Live demos     • POC/pilot  │
│     input         • Site visit    • Reference      • Final      │
│   • Budget        • Deadline        calls            approval   │
│     approval                                                     │
│                                                                  │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Key Decision Factors​

FactorWeightWhat to Evaluate
Functionality25-30%Features match requirements
Ease of use15-20%Interface, learning curve
Total cost20-25%TCO over 3-5 years
Reliability15-20%Uptime, support quality
Scalability10-15%Growth capacity
Vendor stability5-10%Company viability

Requirements Definition​

Functional Requirements Checklist​

Content Management​

RequirementPriorityNotes
Multi-zone layoutsHigh/Med/Low
Playlist schedulingHigh/Med/Low
Content previewHigh/Med/Low
Drag-and-drop interfaceHigh/Med/Low
Role-based accessHigh/Med/Low
Approval workflowsHigh/Med/Low
Template libraryHigh/Med/Low
Content versioningHigh/Med/Low

Media Support​

RequirementPriorityNotes
Images (JPG, PNG)High/Med/Low
Video (H.264, MP4)High/Med/Low
4K resolution supportHigh/Med/Low
HTML5/web contentHigh/Med/Low
Live streamingHigh/Med/Low
YouTube/Vimeo embedHigh/Med/Low
PowerPoint supportHigh/Med/Low
PDF documentsHigh/Med/Low

Scheduling​

RequirementPriorityNotes
Date range schedulingHigh/Med/Low
Day-of-week schedulingHigh/Med/Low
Time-of-day schedulingHigh/Med/Low
Recurring schedulesHigh/Med/Low
Exception datesHigh/Med/Low
Timezone supportHigh/Med/Low
Priority-based overrideHigh/Med/Low
Emergency alertsHigh/Med/Low

Player Management​

RequirementPriorityNotes
Remote monitoringHigh/Med/Low
Remote restartHigh/Med/Low
Screenshot captureHigh/Med/Low
Proof of playHigh/Med/Low
Offline playbackHigh/Med/Low
Local cachingHigh/Med/Low
Auto-recoveryHigh/Med/Low
Firmware updatesHigh/Med/Low

Integration​

RequirementPriorityNotes
REST APIHigh/Med/Low
Single sign-on (SSO)High/Med/Low
Active DirectoryHigh/Med/Low
Data feeds (RSS, JSON)High/Med/Low
Social mediaHigh/Med/Low
POS integrationHigh/Med/Low
Room booking systemsHigh/Med/Low
Emergency systemsHigh/Med/Low

Technical Requirements​

RequirementSpecificationNotes
Supported playersWindows, Android, etc.
Cloud or on-premiseHosting preference
Uptime SLA99.9% or higher
Data residencyGeographic requirements
Security certificationsSOC 2, ISO 27001, etc.
EncryptionTLS 1.2+, at-rest
Backup/recoveryRPO, RTO requirements
Bandwidth requirementsPer player estimate

RFP Template​

Section 1: Company Background​

1.1 Company Overview
    - Company name, location, year founded
    - Number of employees
    - Annual revenue (if public)
    - Key markets/industries served

1.2 Experience
    - Years in digital signage industry
    - Number of customers
    - Number of screens under management
    - References in our industry

1.3 Financial Stability
    - Funding status (private, VC, public)
    - Profitability status
    - Recent acquisitions or mergers
    - Credit references (if applicable)

Section 2: Product Information​

2.1 Solution Overview
    - Describe your digital signage solution
    - Architecture (cloud, on-premise, hybrid)
    - Key differentiators

2.2 Content Management
    - Describe content creation capabilities
    - Supported media formats (with specifications)
    - Template/layout management
    - Content workflow and approval process

2.3 Scheduling
    - Scheduling capabilities
    - Timezone handling
    - Override and priority rules
    - Emergency messaging

2.4 Player Management
    - Supported hardware platforms
    - Monitoring and alerting
    - Remote management capabilities
    - Offline playback behavior
    - Content synchronization method

2.5 Reporting and Analytics
    - Available reports
    - Proof of play capabilities
    - Custom reporting options
    - Data export formats

Section 3: Technical Requirements​

3.1 Infrastructure
    - Hosting options (cloud providers, regions)
    - Data center certifications
    - Disaster recovery capabilities
    - Uptime SLA and historical performance

3.2 Security
    - Security certifications held
    - Encryption (transit and at rest)
    - Authentication options
    - Audit logging capabilities
    - Penetration testing frequency

3.3 Integration
    - API documentation availability
    - Supported authentication methods
    - Rate limits and restrictions
    - Webhook capabilities
    - Pre-built integrations

3.4 Scalability
    - Maximum screens supported
    - Performance at scale
    - Multi-tenant architecture
    - Geographic distribution

Section 4: Implementation​

4.1 Implementation Process
    - Typical implementation timeline
    - Project management approach
    - Migration support (if applicable)
    - Training included

4.2 Professional Services
    - Implementation services offered
    - Content creation services
    - Custom development capabilities
    - Hourly/project rates

4.3 Support
    - Support hours and channels
    - Response time SLAs
    - Escalation process
    - Dedicated account management

Section 5: Pricing​

5.1 Software Pricing
    - License model (subscription, perpetual)
    - Price per screen (by tier if applicable)
    - Feature differences between tiers
    - Minimum commitments
    - Volume discounts

5.2 Hardware Pricing
    - Recommended hardware options
    - Hardware pricing
    - Bundle options

5.3 Professional Services
    - Implementation fees
    - Training costs
    - Custom development rates
    - Content creation rates

5.4 Total Cost
    - Provide 3-year and 5-year TCO for:
      - 10 screens
      - 50 screens
      - 200 screens

Section 6: References​

6.1 Customer References
    - Provide 3 references in our industry
    - Include contact name, title, phone, email
    - Describe scope of their deployment
    - Duration of relationship

6.2 Case Studies
    - Provide relevant case studies
    - Include metrics and outcomes

Vendor Evaluation Scorecard​

Scoring Matrix​

CategoryWeightVendor AVendor BVendor C
Functionality25%/100/100/100
Ease of Use20%/100/100/100
Total Cost20%/100/100/100
Technical Fit15%/100/100/100
Support/Service10%/100/100/100
Vendor Stability10%/100/100/100
WEIGHTED TOTAL100%

Detailed Scoring Criteria​

Functionality (25%)​

CriterionPointsScoring Guide
Core CMS features0-2020=all required, 15=most, 10=some
Media support0-1515=all formats, 10=common, 5=limited
Scheduling0-1515=full featured, 10=adequate, 5=basic
Player management0-1515=comprehensive, 10=standard, 5=basic
Reporting/analytics0-1515=advanced, 10=standard, 5=basic
Integration/API0-2020=extensive, 15=good, 10=basic
Subtotal/100

Ease of Use (20%)​

CriterionPointsScoring Guide
Interface design0-2525=intuitive, 15=acceptable, 5=poor
Learning curve0-2525=quick, 15=moderate, 5=steep
Content creation0-2525=easy, 15=moderate, 5=difficult
Documentation0-2525=comprehensive, 15=adequate, 5=lacking
Subtotal/100

Total Cost (20%)​

CriterionPointsScoring Guide
Software pricing0-3030=competitive, 20=fair, 10=expensive
Implementation costs0-2020=low, 15=reasonable, 5=high
Hidden costs0-2020=none, 10=some, 0=significant
Value for money0-3030=excellent, 20=good, 10=poor
Subtotal/100

Technical Fit (15%)​

CriterionPointsScoring Guide
Platform support0-2525=all needed, 15=most, 5=limited
Security0-2525=exceeds needs, 15=meets, 5=gaps
Scalability0-2525=highly scalable, 15=adequate, 5=limited
Integration capability0-2525=seamless, 15=possible, 5=difficult
Subtotal/100

Support/Service (10%)​

CriterionPointsScoring Guide
Support availability0-2525=24/7, 15=business hours, 5=limited
Response times0-2525=excellent, 15=acceptable, 5=slow
Implementation support0-2525=comprehensive, 15=standard, 5=basic
Account management0-2525=dedicated, 15=shared, 5=none
Subtotal/100

Vendor Stability (10%)​

CriterionPointsScoring Guide
Company size/tenure0-2525=established, 15=growing, 5=startup
Financial health0-2525=strong, 15=stable, 5=uncertain
Customer base0-2525=large/diverse, 15=moderate, 5=small
Market position0-2525=leader, 15=competitor, 5=niche
Subtotal/100

Demo Evaluation Guide​

Pre-Demo Preparation​

TaskComplete
Share requirements in advance[ ]
Define demo scenarios[ ]
Identify attendees and roles[ ]
Prepare questions list[ ]
Set up evaluation forms[ ]

Demo Scenarios to Request​

  1. Content Creation

    • Create a multi-zone layout from scratch
    • Add image, video, and text content
    • Modify an existing template

  2. Scheduling

    • Create a recurring schedule
    • Set up date-specific overrides
    • Configure emergency messaging

  3. Player Management

    • Show real-time player status
    • Demonstrate screenshot capture
    • Show alerting configuration

  4. Reporting

    • Generate proof of play report
    • Export data
    • Show real-time analytics

  5. Integration

    • Display live data feed
    • Show API documentation
    • Demonstrate SSO login

Demo Evaluation Form​

CriterionScore (1-5)Notes
Content Creation
Interface intuitiveness
Template flexibility
Media handling
Scheduling
Ease of schedule creation
Flexibility of rules
Override handling
Player Management
Dashboard clarity
Remote management
Alerting capability
Overall Impression
Response to questions
Technical competence
Fit for our needs

Reference Check Guide​

Questions for References​

General Satisfaction​

  1. How long have you been using this solution?
  2. How many screens do you manage?
  3. What was your primary reason for selecting this vendor?
  4. Would you select them again? Why or why not?

Implementation​

  1. How long did implementation take?
  2. Were there any unexpected challenges?
  3. How was the training?
  4. Did the project stay on budget?

Product Performance​

  1. How reliable is the system?
  2. Have you experienced any significant outages?
  3. How is the content creation experience?
  4. Are there features you wish it had?

Support​

  1. How responsive is their support team?
  2. Have you had any escalation experiences?
  3. How are product updates handled?
  4. Do they proactively communicate?

Business Impact​

  1. Have you seen measurable ROI?
  2. How has it impacted your operations?
  3. Any unexpected benefits or drawbacks?

Reference Check Template​

Reference Company: _______________________
Contact Name/Title: _______________________
Date of Call: _______________________
Screens Deployed: _______________________
Years as Customer: _______________________

SATISFACTION (1-10): _____
Would recommend: Yes / No / Conditional

KEY STRENGTHS:
1. _______________________
2. _______________________
3. _______________________

KEY CONCERNS:
1. _______________________
2. _______________________
3. _______________________

ADDITIONAL NOTES:
_______________________
_______________________

Contract Negotiation​

Key Contract Terms​

TermWhat to Negotiate
PricingVolume discounts, price protection
Term lengthMonthly vs annual, multi-year discount
SLAUptime guarantee, credit for downtime
SupportResponse times, escalation paths
DataOwnership, export capability, retention
TerminationNotice period, data return, fees
LiabilityCap, indemnification
RenewalAuto-renewal terms, price increases

Negotiation Strategies​

StrategyWhen to Use
Multi-year commitmentFor price reduction (15-25%)
Pilot programTest before full deployment
Competitive leverageWhen vendors are close
Bundle servicesFor better overall value
Reference participationFor additional discounts
Early adopterFor new features/products

Contract Checklist​

  • Pricing matches proposal
  • SLA terms defined with remedies
  • Support levels and response times specified
  • Data ownership and portability clear
  • Security and compliance requirements included
  • Termination terms acceptable
  • Auto-renewal terms understood
  • Liability caps appropriate
  • Integration requirements addressed
  • Training and implementation included
  • Change order process defined
  • Escalation contacts identified

Frequently Asked Questions​

Next Steps​

Vendor selection guide maintained by MediaSignage. Templates may be customized for your specific requirements.

Last updated on