Skip to main content

Digital Signage Software Comparison

Choosing the right digital signage software is one of the most important decisions in your deployment. The CMS you select will determine your daily workflow, content capabilities, scalability, and long-term success. This guide provides a systematic approach to evaluating and comparing platforms.

Why Software Choice Matters​

The Stakes Are High​

FactorImpact of Wrong Choice
UsabilityStaff frustration, underutilization
FeaturesLimitations block content goals
ScalabilityPainful migration as you grow
ReliabilityDowntime, blank screens
SupportProblems take longer to resolve
CostOverpaying or surprise fees
Vendor stabilityRisk of platform abandonment

Common Selection Mistakes​

MistakeConsequence
Choosing cheapest optionMissing critical features
Overbuying enterprisePaying for unused complexity
Ignoring hardware compatibilityPlayer limitations
Not testing thoroughlyDiscovering issues post-purchase
Short-term thinkingExpensive migration later
Feature-focused onlyIgnoring support, stability

Evaluation Framework​

Step 1: Define Your Requirements​

Questions to Answer:

CategoryQuestions
ScaleHow many screens now? In 3 years?
LocationsSingle site or multi-location?
Content typesStatic? Video? Interactive? Data-driven?
UsersHow many people manage content?
TechnicalIT resources? Network constraints?
BudgetTotal budget? OpEx vs. CapEx preference?
TimelineWhen must you be operational?

Requirement Priority Matrix:

PriorityDefinitionExamples
Must HaveDeployment fails withoutVideo support, scheduling
Should HaveSignificant valueMulti-zone, templates
Nice to HaveEnhances experienceAnalytics, SSO
Future NeedNot now, but plannedInteractive, API

Step 2: Create Evaluation Criteria​

Weighted Scoring Example:

CriterionWeightYour Priority
Ease of use20%High for small teams
Features25%Varies by needs
Reliability20%Critical for all
Support15%Higher without IT
Price10%Budget-dependent
Scalability10%Growth plans

Step 3: Research Candidates​

Sources for Finding Platforms:

SourceValue
Industry publicationsExpert reviews
G2, CapterraUser reviews
Vendor websitesFeature details
Trade showsLive demos
Peer recommendationsReal experience
Analyst reportsMarket context

Step 4: Hands-On Evaluation​

What to Test:

AreaSpecific Tests
Content creationCreate layouts, add media
SchedulingSet up dayparting, campaigns
Player managementMonitor, control, update
User experienceNon-technical user trial
PerformanceLarge files, many assets
SupportSubmit a question

Feature Comparison Categories​

Content Creation & Design​

FeatureBasicStandardAdvanced
Media uploadImages, video+ Web content+ Streaming
Layout editorFixed zonesDrag-and-drop+ Animation
TemplatesLimitedExtensive+ Custom creation
Text/fontsBasicCustom fonts+ Effects
WidgetsClock, weatherSocial, news+ Custom widgets
Multi-zone2-4 zonesUnlimited+ Responsive

Questions to Ask:

  • Can non-designers create professional content?
  • Are templates customizable and industry-specific?
  • Does it support our file formats?
  • Can we embed web content and live data?

Scheduling & Playlists​

FeatureBasicStandardAdvanced
PlaylistsSimple sequenceNested+ Weighted
SchedulingDate/time+ Recurring+ Rules-based
DaypartingLimitedBy day/time+ Multiple dayparts
PrioritiesNoneBasicFull priority system
TriggersNoneTime-based+ Data/event triggers
Default contentManualConfigurable+ Fallback hierarchy

Questions to Ask:

  • Can we schedule content for specific dates, times, days?
  • How does it handle overlapping schedules?
  • Can external events trigger content changes?
  • What happens if no content is scheduled?

Device Management​

FeatureBasicStandardAdvanced
MonitoringOnline/offline+ Health metrics+ Alerts
Remote controlReboot only+ Screenshot+ Full access
GroupingFlat listHierarchical+ Dynamic groups
UpdatesManualScheduled+ Staged rollout
Offline modeNoneCached content+ Smart caching

Questions to Ask:

  • How quickly do we know if a player is offline?
  • Can we capture screenshots remotely?
  • How are firmware updates managed?
  • What happens during internet outage?

User Management​

FeatureBasicStandardAdvanced
User accountsYesUnlimited+ Bulk management
RolesFixed (2-3)Configurable+ Custom roles
PermissionsBroadGranular+ Per-object
Multi-tenantNoYes+ Hierarchical
AuthenticationPassword+ 2FA+ SSO/SAML
Audit loggingLimitedStandard+ Detailed

Questions to Ask:

  • Can we limit users to specific screens/locations?
  • Is single sign-on supported with our identity provider?
  • Can we create custom permission sets?
  • Is there an approval workflow for content?

Analytics & Reporting​

FeatureBasicStandardAdvanced
Playback logsYesDetailed+ Proof of play
ReportsBasicStandard templates+ Custom
ExportLimitedCSV/PDF+ API access
Player metricsUptime+ Performance+ Predictive
Audience analyticsNoneImpressions+ Demographics
DashboardStaticCustomizable+ Real-time

Questions to Ask:

  • Can we prove specific content played at specific times?
  • Are reports exportable for stakeholders?
  • Can we measure content effectiveness?
  • Is there API access to analytics data?

Integration & API​

FeatureBasicStandardAdvanced
Data feedsRSS+ JSON/XML+ Custom APIs
Third-party appsLimitedCommon apps+ Enterprise
API accessNoneRead+ Read/Write
WebhooksNoneBasic+ Comprehensive
Custom widgetsNoneLimited+ Full SDK
Enterprise systemsNoneStandard+ Deep integration

Questions to Ask:

  • What data sources can we connect?
  • Is there a documented API?
  • Can we build custom integrations?
  • What pre-built integrations exist?

Player Compatibility​

Operating System Support​

PlatformWindowsAndroidLinuxChromeOSSoC
Platform A✓✓✓✗Limited
Platform B✓✓✗✓✓
Platform C✓Limited✓✗✗

Hardware Support​

VendorCommon Support
BrightSignMost platforms
Intel NUCWindows/Linux platforms
Samsung SoCVendor-specific
LG webOSVendor-specific
Raspberry PiLimited platforms
Android boxesMost platforms

Questions to Ask:

  • What players are officially supported?
  • Are there player licensing fees?
  • Can we use hardware we already own?
  • What are minimum hardware requirements?

Pricing Comparison​

Pricing Models​

ModelStructureBest For
Per-screen/monthFixed per displayPredictable scaling
TieredPrice bandsSmall-medium
UnlimitedFlat rateLarge deployments
Per-userBased on usersFew screens, many users
Perpetual + maintenanceLicense + annualOn-premise

Total Cost Considerations​

Cost ElementOne-TimeRecurring
Software license✓ (on-prem)✓ (SaaS)
Player softwareSometimesSometimes
Implementation✓—
Training✓Optional
Support—Usually included
Storage overage—Sometimes
API access—Sometimes premium

Price Transparency​

Red Flags:

  • Pricing not published
  • Many "contact us" features
  • Hidden per-player fees
  • Steep tier jumps
  • Expensive add-ons for basics

Green Flags:

  • Clear, published pricing
  • Free trial available
  • Month-to-month option
  • No long-term contract required
  • All-inclusive pricing

Sample Pricing Comparison​

ScreensPlatform APlatform BPlatform C
5$50/mo$75/moFree
25$250/mo$300/mo$150/mo
100$1,000/mo$800/mo$600/mo
500$4,000/mo$3,000/moCustom

Note: Prices vary significantly. Always get current quotes.

Support & Service Comparison​

Support Channels​

ChannelResponseBest For
PhoneImmediateUrgent issues
Email/ticketHours-1 dayNon-urgent
ChatMinutesQuick questions
Knowledge baseSelf-serviceCommon questions
Community forumVariablePeer help
Dedicated repFastEnterprise

Support Quality Indicators​

IndicatorWhat to Look For
Response timeSLA commitments
Availability24/7 vs. business hours
Technical depthEscalation process
DocumentationComprehensive help center
TrainingOnboarding, videos, webinars
CommunityActive user community

Service Level Agreements (SLAs)​

SLA ElementTypical Values
Uptime99.5% - 99.99%
Response time (critical)1-4 hours
Response time (standard)24-48 hours
Resolution timeVaries by severity
Credits for downtime% of monthly fee

Questions to Ask:

  • What are your support hours?
  • What's the typical response time?
  • Is phone support included?
  • Do you offer onboarding/training?
  • What's your uptime track record?

Vendor Evaluation​

Company Stability​

FactorWhy It Matters
Years in businessExperience, stability
Customer countProven at scale
Funding/financialsLong-term viability
Employee countSupport capacity
Product roadmapFuture development

Red Flags​

Warning SignRisk
New company, no track recordMay not survive
Recent layoffsSupport/development impact
No product updates recentlyStagnant development
Many negative reviewsPattern of issues
Aggressive sales tacticsDesperation
Acquisition rumorsUncertain future

Reference Checks​

Questions for References:

  • How long have you used the platform?
  • What problems have you encountered?
  • How is their support?
  • Would you choose them again?
  • What do you wish you'd known before purchasing?

Comparison Checklist​

Essential Features (Must Evaluate)​

  • Web-based management interface
  • Video file support (MP4, H.264)
  • Multi-zone layout capability
  • Date and time scheduling
  • Playlist creation and management
  • Remote player monitoring
  • Offline playback when internet fails
  • User roles and permissions
  • Content preview before publishing
  • Mobile-responsive management

Important Features (Should Evaluate)​

  • Template library
  • Dayparting (time-of-day scheduling)
  • Remote screenshot capture
  • Remote player reboot/control
  • Player grouping and organization
  • Basic analytics and playback logs
  • Proof of play reporting
  • Two-factor authentication
  • RSS/JSON data feed support
  • Widgets (weather, clock, social)

Advanced Features (Evaluate If Needed)​

  • HTML5/web content support
  • Conditional/trigger scheduling
  • API access (REST)
  • Single Sign-On (SSO/SAML)
  • Approval workflows
  • Interactive/touch content
  • Audience analytics
  • Custom widget development
  • White-labeling capability
  • Enterprise system integration

Non-Feature Criteria​

  • Clear, transparent pricing
  • Free trial available
  • Month-to-month option
  • Published uptime SLA
  • Responsive support (tested)
  • Comprehensive documentation
  • Regular product updates
  • Strong user reviews
  • Compatible with our hardware
  • Vendor financially stable

Evaluation Scorecard Template​

Use this template to score each platform:

CriterionWeightPlatform APlatform BPlatform C
Ease of Use20%
Interface intuitiveness/10/10/10
Learning curve/10/10/10
Features25%
Content creation/10/10/10
Scheduling/10/10/10
Device management/10/10/10
Reliability20%
Uptime SLA/10/10/10
Offline capability/10/10/10
Support15%
Response quality/10/10/10
Documentation/10/10/10
Price10%
Value for cost/10/10/10
Pricing transparency/10/10/10
Scalability10%
Growth capability/10/10/10
Enterprise features/10/10/10
WEIGHTED TOTAL100%

Decision Framework​

When to Choose Enterprise Platforms​

Choose enterprise if:

  • 100+ screens
  • Enterprise SSO/security requirements
  • Complex approval workflows needed
  • Deep system integration required
  • Dedicated support essential
  • Custom development needs

When to Choose Mid-Market Platforms​

Choose mid-market if:

  • 10-100 screens
  • Standard feature needs
  • Some technical capability
  • Budget-conscious but not minimal
  • Growth expected

When to Choose Entry-Level Platforms​

Choose entry-level if:

  • Fewer than 10 screens
  • Simple content (images, basic video)
  • Limited budget
  • Basic scheduling needs
  • Minimal integration requirements

Decision Tree​

START
  │
  ▼
Do you need enterprise security (SSO, compliance)?
  │
  ├── YES ──► Evaluate ENTERPRISE platforms
  │
  ▼ NO
  │
More than 50 screens?
  │
  ├── YES ──► Evaluate ENTERPRISE or MID-MARKET
  │
  ▼ NO
  │
Need advanced integrations or API?
  │
  ├── YES ──► Evaluate MID-MARKET platforms
  │
  ▼ NO
  │
Budget above $20/screen/month?
  │
  ├── NO ──► Evaluate ENTRY-LEVEL platforms
  │
  ▼ YES
  │
Evaluate MID-MARKET platforms

Trial Best Practices​

What to Test During Trial​

AreaTest Actions
ContentUpload images, videos, create layouts
SchedulingSet up dayparts, date ranges
PlayersConnect a test player
UsersCreate additional user, test permissions
SupportSubmit a support request
PerformanceUpload large files, many assets

Trial Evaluation Checklist​

DayFocus
Day 1-2Setup, basic content creation
Day 3-4Scheduling, playlist management
Day 5-6Player setup, monitoring
Day 7-10Advanced features, edge cases
Day 11-14User testing, support evaluation

Questions to Answer Before Trial Ends​

  • Can our team use this without constant help?
  • Does it support all our content types?
  • Is scheduling flexible enough?
  • Were any features missing that we need?
  • How was support when we needed it?
  • Are there any deal-breaker limitations?
  • Does pricing match our budget?
  • Can this scale with our plans?

Frequently Asked Questions​

What is the best digital signage software?​

There's no single "best" platform—it depends on your specific needs. A platform perfect for a small retail chain may be wrong for a large enterprise. Focus on finding the best fit for your requirements rather than an absolute "best."

Should I choose cloud or on-premise software?​

Cloud is right for most deployments—faster to deploy, easier to manage, automatic updates. On-premise makes sense for high-security environments, air-gapped networks, or organizations with strict data residency requirements. See our cloud vs. on-premise guide.

How much should I budget for digital signage software?​

Typical SaaS pricing ranges from $10-30 per screen per month for mid-market platforms. Budget platforms can be under $10, while enterprise platforms may exceed $40. Factor in potential costs for premium features, overage fees, and support tiers.

How long should I trial software before deciding?​

Take the full trial period offered—typically 14-30 days. Spend at least 2 weeks actively testing. Involve multiple team members who will use the system. Test support by submitting real questions.

Summary​

Choosing digital signage software is a significant decision. Follow this process:

  1. Define requirements — Know what you need before looking
  2. Research candidates — Create a shortlist of 3-5 platforms
  3. Compare features — Use the evaluation framework
  4. Evaluate vendors — Consider stability, support, roadmap
  5. Test thoroughly — Take full advantage of trials
  6. Score objectively — Use weighted criteria
  7. Check references — Talk to existing customers
  8. Decide based on fit — Best fit, not just best features

This guide is maintained by MediaSignage, pioneers in digital signage technology since 2008.

Last updated on