Video Encoding for Digital Signage

Video content dominates digital signage, but improper encoding leads to playback failures, poor quality, excessive bandwidth, and frustrated deployments. This comprehensive guide covers everything you need to know about encoding video for reliable digital signage playback.

---

Video Encoding Fundamentals

The Encoding Pipeline

Source Video → Decode → Process → Encode → Container → Distribute → Decode → Display

Key Decisions:
├── Codec: How video is compressed (H.264, HEVC, AV1)
├── Container: File format wrapper (MP4, MKV, MOV)
├── Resolution: Frame dimensions (1920×1080, 3840×2160)
├── Bitrate: Data rate (quality vs. file size)
├── Frame Rate: Frames per second (24, 30, 60 fps)
└── Profile/Level: Codec capability subset

Why Encoding Matters for Signage

Common Problems from Poor Encoding:

• Playback stuttering or freezing
• Audio/video sync issues
• Player crashes
• Excessive storage consumption
• Network congestion
• Display compatibility failures
• Color/quality degradation

Properly Encoded Video Delivers:

• Reliable 24/7 playback
• Consistent quality across devices
• Efficient bandwidth utilization
• Reduced storage costs
• Simplified content management

---

Video Codec Comparison

Major Codecs for Digital Signage

Codec	Also Known As	Released	Compression	Support Level
H.264	AVC, MPEG-4 Part 10	2003	Good	Universal
H.265	HEVC	2013	Excellent	Good
VP9	-	2013	Excellent	Good
AV1	-	2018	Best	Growing
MPEG-2	H.262	1995	Poor	Legacy
MPEG-4 Part 2	DivX, Xvid	1999	Poor	Legacy

H.264/AVC (Recommended for Most Deployments)

Why H.264 Remains the Standard:

• Universal hardware decode support
• Mature, well-optimized encoders
• Extensive player compatibility
• Reasonable file sizes
• Well-documented behavior

H.264 Profiles:

Profile	Use Case	Features
Baseline	Legacy devices, mobile	I and P frames, no CABAC
Main	Standard signage	B frames, CABAC
High	HD/4K content	8×8 transform, additional tools
High 10	HDR content	10-bit color depth
High 4:2:2	Broadcast, professional	4:2:2 chroma

Recommended: High Profile for modern signage players

H.264 Levels:

Level	Max Resolution	Max Bitrate	Use Case
3.1	1280×720	14 Mbps	720p signage
4.0	2048×1024	20 Mbps	1080p standard
4.1	2048×1024	50 Mbps	1080p high quality
4.2	2048×1088	50 Mbps	1080p 60fps
5.0	3840×2160	135 Mbps	4K 30fps
5.1	4096×2160	240 Mbps	4K 60fps

H.265/HEVC (For 4K and Advanced Deployments)

Advantages:

• 40-50% better compression than H.264
• Essential for 4K content
• HDR/WCG support
• Growing hardware support

Considerations:

• Requires modern hardware decode
• Licensing complexity
• Slower encoding
• Not universal yet

HEVC Profiles:

Profile	Features	Use Case
Main	8-bit, 4:2:0	Standard 4K signage
Main 10	10-bit, 4:2:0	HDR content
Main 4:2:2 10	10-bit, 4:2:2	Professional/broadcast

Player Support Matrix:

Platform	HEVC Hardware Decode
Windows (Intel 6th gen+)	Yes
Windows (AMD 2016+)	Yes
Windows (NVIDIA 900+)	Yes
Android (2016+)	Most devices
Raspberry Pi 4/5	Yes
BrightSign (HD/XD/XT)	Yes
Chrome OS	Varies by device
Smart TVs (2017+)	Most models

AV1 (Future Standard)

Advantages:

• 30% better than HEVC
• Royalty-free
• Growing hardware support
• Best for 4K/8K

Current Limitations:

• Limited hardware decode (2020+ devices)
• Slower encoding
• Not yet universal
• Player support varies

AV1 Timeline:

• 2024-2025: Growing hardware support
• 2026+: Becoming mainstream option

VP9 (Alternative for Specific Platforms)

Use Cases:

• YouTube/Google ecosystem
• Web-based players
• Chrome devices
• Android primary

Limitations:

• Less universal than H.264
• Fewer hardware decoders
• Google-centric ecosystem

---

Codec Selection Guide

Decision Matrix

Select Your Codec:

Need universal compatibility?
├── Yes → H.264 High Profile
└── No ↓

Is 4K content primary?
├── Yes → HEVC (verify player support)
└── No ↓

Bandwidth severely limited?
├── Yes → HEVC or AV1 (if supported)
└── No ↓

Web-based player only?
├── Yes → H.264 or VP9
└── No ↓

Default recommendation → H.264 High Profile

Platform-Specific Recommendations

Platform	Primary Codec	Secondary	Avoid
Windows Players	H.264	HEVC	MPEG-2
BrightSign	H.264	HEVC	VP9
Android/SoC	H.264	HEVC	AV1 (older)
Raspberry Pi 4+	H.264	HEVC	VP9
Chrome OS	H.264	VP9	HEVC (some)
Samsung Tizen	H.264	HEVC	VP9
LG webOS	H.264	HEVC	AV1
Web Players	H.264	VP9	HEVC

---

Resolution and Frame Rate

Resolution Guidelines

Display Resolution	Source Resolution	Notes
1920×1080 (FHD)	1920×1080	Native 1:1
3840×2160 (4K)	3840×2160	Native 1:1
1080×1920 (Portrait FHD)	1080×1920	Encode portrait
2160×3840 (Portrait 4K)	2160×3840	Encode portrait
Video Wall (custom)	Match total pixels	Or per-screen segments

Resolution Best Practices:

• Match source to display native resolution
• Never upscale source content
• Encode in display orientation (portrait/landscape)
• Video walls: Encode at total wall resolution

Frame Rate Selection

Content Type	Recommended FPS	Notes
Static/text heavy	24-30 fps	Lower = smaller files
General signage	30 fps	Good balance
Smooth motion	60 fps	Sports, smooth scroll
Cinematic content	24 fps	Film look
Animation	30 fps	Sufficient fluidity

Frame Rate Rules:

• Match source frame rate (don't convert 24 → 30)
• Use constant frame rate (not variable)
• 60 fps only when motion requires it
• Higher fps = larger files, more processing

Aspect Ratio Handling

Scenario	Approach
16:9 content → 16:9 display	Direct playback
4:3 content → 16:9 display	Pillarbox or crop
16:9 content → 9:16 portrait	Letterbox, crop, or re-edit
Non-standard → Standard	Encode to target with padding

---

Bitrate Optimization

Understanding Bitrate

Bitrate = File Size / Duration

• Higher bitrate = better quality, larger files
• Lower bitrate = smaller files, potential quality loss
• Balance: Sufficient quality with efficient file size

Recommended Bitrates

H.264 Bitrate Guidelines:

Resolution	Low Motion	Medium Motion	High Motion
720p (30fps)	2-4 Mbps	4-6 Mbps	6-8 Mbps
1080p (30fps)	4-6 Mbps	6-10 Mbps	10-15 Mbps
1080p (60fps)	6-10 Mbps	10-15 Mbps	15-20 Mbps
4K (30fps)	15-20 Mbps	20-35 Mbps	35-50 Mbps
4K (60fps)	25-35 Mbps	35-50 Mbps	50-80 Mbps

HEVC Bitrate Guidelines (30-40% lower than H.264):

Resolution	Low Motion	Medium Motion	High Motion
1080p (30fps)	3-4 Mbps	4-7 Mbps	7-10 Mbps
4K (30fps)	10-15 Mbps	15-25 Mbps	25-35 Mbps
4K (60fps)	18-25 Mbps	25-35 Mbps	35-55 Mbps

VBR vs. CBR

Constant Bitrate (CBR):

• Fixed data rate throughout
• Predictable file sizes
• Predictable bandwidth
• Quality varies with content complexity

Variable Bitrate (VBR):

• Adapts to content complexity
• Better quality per bit
• Less predictable file sizes
• More efficient overall

Recommendation: VBR with constrained maximum (capped VBR)

Encoding Settings:

Constrained VBR Example:
- Target bitrate: 8 Mbps
- Maximum bitrate: 12 Mbps
- VBV buffer: 1.5× target = 12 Mbit

Result: Quality adapts to content, never exceeds 12 Mbps

Calculating Storage Requirements

File Size (GB) = (Bitrate in Mbps × Duration in seconds) / 8 / 1024

Example:
- 8 Mbps video
- 60 seconds
- Size = (8 × 60) / 8 / 1024 = 0.059 GB ≈ 60 MB

Daily Loop (8 hours, various content):
- Average 6 Mbps
- 28,800 seconds
- Size = (6 × 28800) / 8 / 1024 = 21.1 GB

---

Container Formats

Containers vs. Codecs

Container = File format (packaging) Codec = Compression method (content)

Example: video.mp4

Container: MP4 (MPEG-4 Part 14)
├── Video track: H.264 codec
├── Audio track: AAC codec
└── Metadata: Duration, chapters, etc.

Container Comparison

Container	Extension	H.264	HEVC	AV1	Signage Use
MP4	.mp4	✓	✓	✓	Recommended
MOV	.mov	✓	✓	✓	Mac-origin
MKV	.mkv	✓	✓	✓	Flexible
WebM	.webm	✗	✗	✓	Web players
AVI	.avi	✓	✗	✗	Legacy
TS	.ts	✓	✓	✗	Streaming

Recommendation: MP4 for maximum compatibility

MP4 Best Practices

Moov Atom Placement:

• Place at file start (fast start/web optimized)
• Enables immediate playback without full download
• Critical for network-delivered content

FFmpeg Command:

-movflags +faststart

---

Audio Encoding

Audio Codec Selection

Codec	Quality	Compatibility	Use Case
AAC-LC	Good	Universal	Default choice
AAC-HE	Good (low bitrate)	Good	Bandwidth limited
MP3	Acceptable	Universal	Legacy
AC3/Dolby	Good	HDMI output	AV systems
Opus	Excellent	Growing	Web, modern
PCM	Perfect	Large files	Archival

Recommendation: AAC-LC for universal signage

Audio Bitrate Guidelines

Quality Level	Stereo Bitrate	Typical Use
Background	64-96 kbps	Ambient, low priority
Standard	128 kbps	General signage
Good	192 kbps	Music-focused
High	256-320 kbps	Premium audio

Audio Sample Rate

Sample Rate	Use Case
44.1 kHz	Music, CD-quality
48 kHz	Video standard (recommended)
96 kHz	Professional audio

Recommendation: 48 kHz to match video standards

Channel Configuration

Channels	Configuration	Notes
1	Mono	Simple, small files
2	Stereo	Standard
5.1	Surround	Requires compatible output

Signage Recommendation: Stereo (2 channel) at 48 kHz, 128-192 kbps AAC

---

Encoding Tools and Settings

Professional Tools

Software Encoders:

Tool	Type	Best For
FFmpeg	Command-line	Automation, batch
HandBrake	GUI	Individual files
Adobe Media Encoder	GUI	Creative workflow
DaVinci Resolve	GUI	Color grading + encode
Compressor (Apple)	GUI	Apple ecosystem

Hardware Encoders:

• NVIDIA NVENC
• Intel QuickSync
• AMD VCE
• Apple VideoToolbox

FFmpeg Reference Commands

Standard 1080p H.264 for Signage:

ffmpeg -i input.mp4 \
  -c:v libx264 \
  -preset medium \
  -profile:v high \
  -level 4.1 \
  -crf 18 \
  -maxrate 10M \
  -bufsize 15M \
  -c:a aac \
  -b:a 192k \
  -ar 48000 \
  -movflags +faststart \
  output.mp4

4K HEVC for Modern Players:

ffmpeg -i input.mp4 \
  -c:v libx265 \
  -preset medium \
  -profile:v main \
  -crf 20 \
  -maxrate 25M \
  -bufsize 37M \
  -c:a aac \
  -b:a 192k \
  -ar 48000 \
  -movflags +faststart \
  output.mp4

Portrait Mode Encoding (1080×1920):

ffmpeg -i input.mp4 \
  -vf "scale=1080:1920:force_original_aspect_ratio=decrease,pad=1080:1920:(ow-iw)/2:(oh-ih)/2" \
  -c:v libx264 \
  -preset medium \
  -crf 18 \
  -c:a aac \
  -b:a 192k \
  -movflags +faststart \
  output.mp4

Batch Encoding Script (Bash):

#!/bin/bash
for file in *.mp4; do
  ffmpeg -i "$file" \
    -c:v libx264 -preset medium -crf 18 \
    -c:a aac -b:a 192k \
    -movflags +faststart \
    "encoded/${file%.mp4}_signage.mp4"
done

Quality Settings Explained

CRF (Constant Rate Factor):

• Range: 0-51 (lower = better quality, larger files)
• 18: Visually lossless for most content
• 20-22: Excellent quality, good compression
• 23-25: Good quality, smaller files
• 26+: Noticeable quality loss

Preset (Encoding Speed):

Preset	Speed	Compression	Use
ultrafast	Fastest	Poorest	Testing only
veryfast	Very fast	Poor	Real-time
faster	Fast	Below average	Quick jobs
fast	Fast	Average	Daily use
medium	Medium	Good	Recommended
slow	Slow	Better	Final encode
slower	Slower	Even better	Quality priority
veryslow	Slowest	Best	Maximum quality

Recommendation: medium preset with crf 18-20

---

Common Issues and Solutions

Playback Problems

Symptom	Likely Cause	Solution
Video won't play	Codec incompatibility	Re-encode with H.264
Stuttering/choppy	Bitrate too high	Reduce bitrate or resolution
Audio out of sync	VFR source	Convert to CFR
Black screen with audio	Hardware decode failure	Check player codec support
Freezing mid-playback	Corrupt file	Re-encode, check source
Color looks wrong	Color space mismatch	Set bt709 color space
Blocky artifacts	Bitrate too low	Increase bitrate

Variable Frame Rate (VFR) Issues

Problem: Many phone/screen recordings use VFR, causing playback issues.

Detection:

ffprobe -v error -select_streams v:0 \
  -show_entries stream=r_frame_rate,avg_frame_rate \
  input.mp4

If r_frame_rate ≠ avg_frame_rate, content may be VFR.

Solution - Convert to CFR:

ffmpeg -i input.mp4 \
  -vsync cfr \
  -r 30 \
  [other options] \
  output.mp4

Color Space Issues

Standard for SDR Signage:

-colorspace bt709 -color_primaries bt709 -color_trc bt709

Full FFmpeg Example:

ffmpeg -i input.mp4 \
  -c:v libx264 -crf 18 \
  -colorspace bt709 \
  -color_primaries bt709 \
  -color_trc bt709 \
  -c:a aac \
  output.mp4

File Size Optimization

When Files Are Too Large:

1. Reduce bitrate (try CRF 22-24)
2. Lower resolution if viewing distance allows
3. Use HEVC if players support it
4. Reduce frame rate for low-motion content
5. Optimize source content (remove unnecessary complexity)

When Quality Is Insufficient:

1. Verify source quality is good
2. Lower CRF (try 16-18)
3. Increase bitrate limits
4. Use slower encoding preset
5. Check for VFR issues

---

Encoding Workflow

Production Workflow

Content Creation Workflow:

1. PRODUCTION
   ├── Shoot/create at highest practical quality
   └── Export masters in production codec (ProRes, DNxHD)

2. ARCHIVAL
   ├── Keep production masters
   └── Create high-quality archive version

3. SIGNAGE ENCODE
   ├── Encode from archival master (not production master)
   ├── Target specific player requirements
   └── Create multiple versions if needed

4. QUALITY CHECK
   ├── Test on target hardware
   ├── Verify playback performance
   └── Check sync, color, audio

5. DEPLOYMENT
   ├── Upload to CMS
   ├── Verify delivery
   └── Monitor playback

Multi-Platform Encoding

When supporting multiple player types:

Source Master
     │
     ├──► H.264 High Profile (universal)
     │    └── Resolution/bitrate for weakest player
     │
     ├──► HEVC Main Profile (4K players)
     │    └── Higher quality, smaller files
     │
     └──► WebM/VP9 (web players)
          └── Browser compatibility

---

Frequently Asked Questions

---

Summary

Universal Signage Encoding Settings:

Codec: H.264 High Profile (Level 4.1 for 1080p, 5.0 for 4K)
Container: MP4 with fast start
Resolution: Match display native
Frame Rate: 30 fps (60 for smooth motion)
Bitrate: 6-10 Mbps (1080p) / 20-35 Mbps (4K)
Audio: AAC-LC, 192 kbps, 48 kHz, Stereo

Key Principles:

1. Always verify player codec support before encoding
2. Match resolution to display native resolution
3. Use constant frame rate (CFR), not variable (VFR)
4. Enable fast start for MP4 files
5. Test on actual target hardware before deployment
6. Keep source masters for re-encoding needs

Proper video encoding prevents playback failures, optimizes bandwidth, and ensures consistent quality across your digital signage network.